Home › Assistive Technology › Shower chair vs transfer bench

Equipment

Shower Chair vs Transfer Bench: Which One Fits?

If the person bathes in a bathtub and has to step over the wall, a transfer bench is usually the safer choice, because it lets them sit down first and then slide across. If they bathe in a walk-in shower and can step in, a shower chair fits better and takes less room. Measure the space and check your model’s weight rating first.

Knowals is reader-supported. Some links on this page are affiliate links, which means we may earn a small commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. We only include equipment we would put in front of a family member. We never accept payment to feature a product.

Shower chair vs transfer bench, side by side

Which describes the person you care for

Walks with help. They can stand for a short time, sit down with a hand at the hips, and follow simple instructions. This page is written for you. A shower chair or a transfer bench is the right category.

Uses a wheelchair but can bear some weight. A sliding transfer bench or a rolling shower commode chair is more likely to work than a plain shower chair. Ask an occupational therapist to look at your bathroom doorway width before you buy anything with wheels.

Cannot bear weight at all. Neither device on this page is appropriate. You need a rolling shower commode chair, a roll-in shower, or a full-body lift with a bathing sling, and usually two caregivers.

If that last one describes the person you care for, read our full-body lift guide instead, and get a hands-on assessment first.

How to choose: what actually matters

Four things decide this, in this order.

1. Tub or walk-in shower

This settles most of it. A standard tub wall is roughly knee height on many adults. Lifting a leg over it while standing on one wet foot is the single riskiest moment in the bathroom.

If it is a tub, start with a transfer bench. If it is a curbless or low-curb walk-in shower, a shower chair is enough.

2. Weight capacity

Ratings vary widely by model. Read the rating on the box or in the manual for the exact model you are buying, and do not assume it matches another product you have seen. Leave margin. A person leaning hard on one armrest loads that frame unevenly.

3. Backrest and arms, or a plain stool

A stool is cheaper and fits a small shower. It suits someone with steady trunk control who just cannot stand long enough to wash. Add a backrest if they lean back, tire, or get washed by someone else. Add armrests if they need something to push up from.

Armrests are also the thing most likely to make a chair too wide for a narrow shower, so measure your stall interior and compare it with the listed overall width.

If the person is under hip precautions, seat height matters more than any of this. Choose a model whose legs adjust high enough to keep the hips level with or above the knees.

A plain stool has its own cost. There is nothing to push off and nothing behind the shoulders. If the person ever leans back to rinse their hair, they will find air. A stool is not appropriate for anyone whose balance changes through the day.

4. Grab bar placement

Equipment does not replace a grab bar. For a shower chair, a vertical bar at the entry gives something to hold while stepping in, and a horizontal bar near the seat helps with sitting and standing.

For a transfer bench, the useful bar is usually vertical, on the wall at the outside end, where the person stands before sitting. Bars must be fastened into studs or proper blocking by someone who knows how. Suction-mounted bars are for balance cues only, not for taking weight.

Marketing noise: designer finishes, thick padding that stays damp and grows mildew, and “tool-free assembly” as a headline feature. None of those change whether someone falls. More options are in our bathroom safety equipment guide.

Setting up and using a shower chair

1. Assemble the chair on a dry floor, following the manual. Legs often snap into holes with a spring button, and a button that has not clicked fully will collapse under load.
2. Set the chair inside the shower with all four feet flat.
3. Adjust each leg so the person’s feet rest flat on the floor when seated. Hips slightly higher than knees makes standing up much easier and safer.
4. Press hard on each corner of the seat. Any rock now becomes a fall later.
5. Turn the chair so the back is toward the wall and the front faces the door.
6. Put your own non-slip shoes on before you step into the wet area.
7. Run the water and test it on the inside of your own wrist or forearm, never on the person’s skin.
8. Turn the water off, or aim the spray at the far wall, before the person comes in. A jet of water landing on someone mid step makes them flinch.
9. Ask the person to hold the grab bar with their stronger hand.
10. Take your position on their weaker side, feet apart, knees soft, within arm’s reach.
11. Guide them to step in with one leg at a time.
12. Ask them to back up until the backs of their legs touch the seat.
13. Tell them to reach back for the armrests or the seat edge.
14. Keep your hands at their hips as they lower down. Your hands steady and direct them. They are not there to take their weight.
15. Confirm they are fully back on the seat before you let go.
16. Retest the water on your wrist, then bring the spray to their body and keep it moving.

Test the water every single time, no matter what the person says. If they have neuropathy, diabetes, stroke, MS, or a spinal cord injury, they may not feel scalding water or be able to tell you in time.

Keep the spray moving once they are seated. A seated bather cannot step out of the stream, so water resting on one patch of skin can burn.

After hip surgery, a higher seat also helps keep the operated hip from bending too far. Check the hip precautions before you set the leg height.

Setting up and using a transfer bench

1. Assemble the bench on the bathroom floor, following the manual.
2. Lower the two inside legs into the tub.
3. Rest the two outside legs on the bathroom floor.
4. Adjust the inside legs until the seat sits level, or very slightly sloped toward the tub if your manual allows it. A seat sloped away sends water onto your floor.
5. Set the seat height so the person’s hips stay level with or above their knees when seated. A low seat is hard to rise from.
6. Push down hard on all four corners of the seat.
7. Place a non-slip mat on the tub floor.
8. Place a second non-slip mat on the floor outside the tub.
9. Move soap, shampoo, and the handheld shower head within reach of the inside seat.
10. Put your own non-slip shoes on before you start the transfer.
11. Run the water and test it on the inside of your own wrist or forearm, never on the person’s skin.
12. Turn the water off, or aim the spray away from the seat, before the person comes in.
13. Lock the seat carriage now if your bench has a sliding seat. The seat must not move at the moment their weight lands on it.
14. Take your position at the outer end of the bench, feet apart, knees soft, within arm’s reach.
15. Ask the person to back up until their legs touch the outer part of the bench.
16. Tell them to reach back for the bench or the armrest.
17. Keep your hands at their hips as they sit down on the outer section. You are guiding, not holding them up.
18. Confirm they are fully seated with both feet supported before you let go.
19. Fixed-seat bench only: ask them to push with their hands and shift toward the tub, a few inches at a time. Small shifts protect the skin.
20. Sliding-seat bench only: unlock the carriage once they are fully seated with both feet supported. On a sliding model the seat travels, the person does not.
21. Sliding-seat bench only: move the carriage toward the tub in short travels, with your hand on the seat, checking their feet stay supported.
22. Sliding-seat bench only: re-lock the carriage as soon as the seat reaches the inside position, and check the lock has engaged.
23. Help lift one leg over the tub wall, supporting it under the calf and the heel, with the knee and toes pointing up.
24. Help lift the second leg the same way. Move each leg as one unit rather than twisting it.
25. Check that their hips are fully inside the tub line before you start the water.
26. Retest the water on your wrist, then bring the spray to their body and keep it moving.
27. Reverse every step to get out, turning the water off first and re-locking a sliding carriage at the outer end before they stand.

The carriage must be locked before anyone stands, leans, or shifts weight. Follow your model’s manual for the exact locking sequence. Never ask someone to drag themselves across a locked sliding seat.

Dragging across a wet plastic seat causes shearing and skin tears, especially on thin older skin. That is why a fixed seat gets small shifts and a sliding seat gets moved for them.

Supporting the leg under the calf and heel keeps the knee and toes pointing up and keeps the leg from crossing midline, which is what posterior hip precautions require. Stop if there is pain, a clunk, or resistance.

Recent hip surgery: read before you use a bench

If the person has had recent hip surgery, ask their surgeon or therapist which hip precautions apply before using a bench or any bath seat. The precautions decide how high the seat has to be.

• Do not bend the operated hip past 90 degrees.
• Do not let the operated leg cross the midline of the body.
• Do not rotate the operated leg inward.
• Set the seat high enough that the hips stay level with or above the knees when they sit.
• When you help a leg over the tub wall, support it under the calf and the heel, keep the knee and toes pointing up, and move it as one unit.
• Stop if there is pain, a clunk, or resistance, and call the surgeon’s office.

Call 911 if the hip pops out of place, the person cannot move the leg, or the leg looks shortened or turned in or out.

If the person starts to go down

Never try to catch or hold up a person who is falling. You will both go down, and on a wet floor next to a tub rim that is how caregivers get hurt and how the person hits their head.

Widen your stance, keep your back straight, bring them in close against your body, protect their head with your hand or forearm, and lower them to the floor in a controlled way. Then stop. Do not attempt to lift them off the floor yourself.

Call 911 immediately if any of these apply.

• They hit their head
• They take a blood thinner or any anticoagulant
• They lost consciousness, even briefly
• They cannot move a limb
• There is an obvious deformity, or one leg looks shortened or rotated
• They have severe pain
• You cannot rouse them fully

Stay with them, do not move them, and keep them warm while you wait.

If none of those red flags apply, keep them warm and supported on the floor, put a towel or folded blanket under their head, and call for help. Do not lift them alone. Have them checked by a clinician before any further transfer that day, even if they say they are fine.

Where to stand: stay within arm’s reach on the person’s weaker side, slightly to the side rather than directly in front, with your feet apart, one foot forward, and your knees soft. From there you can steady a wobble without stepping and without reaching across your own body.

Common mistakes

• Buying a shower chair for a bathtub. The chair solves standing. It does nothing about the tub wall, which is the part people fall over.
• Trusting suction cup feet. They fail on textured tub bottoms, non-slip factory tread, tile grout lines, and soap film, which describes most bathrooms.
• Setting the seat too low. A low seat is hard to get off, and after hip surgery it can bend the operated hip past the surgeon’s limit.
• Ignoring hip precautions. Lifting a leg over a tub wall is exactly the movement that can bend, twist, or cross the operated hip. Get the precautions in writing first.
• Skipping the rock test. Four legs on an uneven tub floor almost never land even on the first try.
• Grabbing the shower door or towel bar. Neither is anchored for body weight. Both come off the wall.
• Leaving the person to fetch a towel. Bring everything in first. Wet, cold, and alone is when people try to stand on their own.
• Using a plastic patio chair or a kitchen stool. They are not rated for wet use, they slide, and the legs splay.
• Not locking a sliding seat or a rolling chair’s casters. The seat moves at exactly the moment weight lands on it.
• Dragging someone across a locked sliding seat. On a sliding bench the seat is supposed to do the moving. Dragging skin across wet plastic is how skin tears happen.
• Trying to catch a falling person. Guide them down and protect their head instead. Catching turns one injury into two.
• Treating every fall as a wait-and-see. A head strike, a blood thinner, a lost limb movement, a deformed leg, severe pain, or lost consciousness is a 911 call.
• Judging water temperature by the person’s report. Reduced sensation is common and often unnoticed. Your wrist is the test, every time.

The two we would put in a family member’s bathroom

These are the models that match the two categories above. Check the rating, the seat dimensions, and your own measurements against the listing before you order either one.

Sliding models add moving parts that need rinsing and inspection, and they add a locking routine you have to get right every time. If the need may be short term, borrowing is the better call. See the next section.

Paying for it, and when not to buy at all

Medicare Part B covers durable medical equipment that is medically necessary and prescribed for use in the home. Bath safety items are frequently treated as convenience items and denied.

Medicare and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services publish the general rules, and your regional contractor applies them. Rolling shower commode chairs sometimes fare better than plain benches, though nothing is automatic.

Medicaid coverage varies a great deal by state. Private plans vary by policy, so call the number on the card and ask specifically about bath safety equipment. Our guide to paying for equipment goes through the options.

Before you spend anything, call a loan closet. Senior centers, faith communities, hospital discharge planners, Area Agencies on Aging, and disease-specific organizations including the ALS Association often keep shower chairs and benches to lend free or for a small deposit.

If the need is short term, after a hip replacement for example, borrowing is simply the right answer. Ask the surgical team for the hip precautions at the same time, since the precautions decide how high the seat has to be.

Borrowing also lets you try a bench in your bathroom before committing to one. For an expensive rolling shower commode, renting through a DME supplier for a month often beats buying the wrong thing.

Common questions

Ask your occupational therapist or physical therapist to watch you do this before you rely on it. A short in-person check catches things no written guide can.

This guide is educational and does not replace hands-on training. Before using any transfer equipment, have a physical or occupational therapist assess the person you care for and demonstrate the technique in person. Always follow the manufacturer instructions for your specific model.

Related